The head of Britain’s Financial Services Authority says that disclosure is not enough to eliminate conflicts in the insurance industry.
Speaking at the FSA’s first insurance sector conference Thursday, FSA chief executive John Tiner said the FSA believes the industry is capable of managing conflicts of interest, but that mandatory commission disclosure would not be sufficient to resolve conflicts. The FSA assumed responsibility for general insurance regulation in January.
“Full disclosure would not be a panacea, nor provide a safe harbour from the need to manage conflicts: they would still be present and they would still have to be managed,” he said. “The management of conflicts is not the responsibility of the regulator: our responsibility is to set the principles… and assess compliance with our principles. We are doing that right now through our work on conflicts management and if we find serious breaches or ignorance of our requirements we will take appropriate action against the firms and individuals involved.”
“Management responsibility lies with the people in the firms. It lies in the culture of the firms, in the operations of the firms and in the business models of the firms,” he added.
Tiner also emphasized that the FSA would support industry efforts to develop market-based solutions to perceived problems. “The wholesale insurance market is a professional market; a market where we will only intervene where it is appropriate to do so; and a market in which we are prepared to rely on market solutions where there is a real chance that they will work.”
“The door is not closed on regulatory intervention, but in a world where there are calls for less regulation generally, calls for less gold-plating of directives and calls for less prescription overall, immediate regulatory intervention without clear evidence of market failure would be incompatible with [our] approach and philosophy,” he added.
Disclosure not enough, FSA says
Management of conflicts not the responsibility of the regulator
- By: James Langton
- April 7, 2005 April 7, 2005
- 10:51